About that reading of the Constitution

Last night on Facebook, I tried to calm some folks down who were upset that the House of Representatives read an “amended” version of the Constitution.  But they were too hysterical to see where they were wrong.

While it is true that some parts were “omitted,” it is not true that the entire Constitution was not read.  The parts omitted were those sections that have been amended or repealed.  In other words, it didn’t make a lot of sense yesterday to read about Prohibition, because it’s not in there any more.

What’s most amusing is that the complaints were started by the left, but picked up by the right in a bit of “we don’t know what we’re talking about” hysteria.

Over at Power Line, there’s a bit more explanation, and a good admonition to Read it Again, John.

But if the purpose of the reading was to remind people of the contents of our fundamental law and to symbolize Congress’ commitment to adhering to that law, then it makes no sense to read portions of document that no longer apply. The reading Jackson and others wanted would make sense only if this were a history lesson. But it was not. History lessons are for speeches by individual members, each of whom has his or her own view about which aspects of history to emphasize. What all members of Congress have in common is their oath to uphold the Constitution as it stands today.

So, if there was any real “show” yesterday, it was from the left showing their disdain for the Constitution.  But in a venue across the street it was from the right showing their tendency to react first and possibly consider the facts later.

UPDATE:  As soon as I hit post, I saw a tweet from Jamie Dupree’s Washington Insider that shows that, while still a good thing, a little bit of clumsiness did actually mar the full reading yesterday. “The problem started when Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-NY) finished his reading, because the next lamwaker, Rep. Jeff Fortenberry (R-NE), picked up the reading in Article 5. Either Nadler inadvertently turned two pages of the constitutional script that was on the lectern in the House Well when he finished, or a page had been left out by Republicans…Organizer Rep. Bob Goodlatte (R-VA) came down to the House floor several hours later to read the missed portions into the record of debate.”

Sigh…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

slot777situs luar gacorslot toto gacorslot mahjongslot gacor hari inislot server luarslot mahjong gacorsitus luar gacorlink gacor maxwinslot gacor maxwinslot luar negerislot 88slot toto gacorslot luar negerislot gacor 88slot maxwinslot toto gacorslot gacor maxwinlink alternatif pacutoto99slot gacor maxwinslot toto gacorslot gacor 4dslot maxwinslot 4d gacorsitus slot gacorslot gacor maxwinslot maxwinslot totoslot server luarslot luar gacormaxwin totositus luar gacorsitus slot gacorslot toto gacorsitus luar gacortoto gacorslot totoslot luar gacorsitus luar gacorslot server luarslot toto gacortoto gacorslot totoslot luar gacorsitus luar gacorslot gacor maxwinslot server luarslot luar gacorslot gacor maxwinmaxwin totolink gacor maxwinslot gacormaxwin slotslot maxwinslot gacor maxwinslot toto gacor maxwinslot maxwinslot asiaslot server luarslot jepangslot server asiaslot luar negerislot server thailandspaceman slotslot 4dthailand slotserver jepang gacorasia slotslot gacor maxwintoto slot gacorslot thailand resmiserver thailand slotserver jepang slotserver asia slotserver malaysia slotserver luar slotserver macau slotserver hongkong slotslot luar 4dslot toto gacorslot server thailandslot server luar negerislot dana 5000slot thailandslot server jepangslot server luarslot luar negeri 4dslot dana gacorsitus toto gacorslot toto gacorslot server luarpacutoto99 link alternatifslot gacor 4dslot server thailandslot server luarslot dana 5000slot toto gacorslot luarslot luar negeritotoslot luar 4dws168toto slotslot gacor maxwinslot totoslot maxwinslot luar 4dslot luarslot asiatoto gacorslot totoslot gacor 4dslot gacor server luar hari inislot toto gacorslot onlinesabung ayam onlineslot server luarslot server thailandslot totoslot gacor server luar hari inislot toto gacorslot server luarslot luar negerisv388slot thailanddigmaanslot totoslot server luarsv388slot thailandsv388slot totosv388digmaanws168slot totoslot server thailanddigmaanslot totopacutoto99luarsv388ws168totopacutoto99pacutoto99pacutoto99